
In what was reported as the biggest dog-fighting ring bust in the history of US law enforcement, in July of this year authorities arrested 26 people and seized more than 500 dogs, mostly pit bulls, across eight states (Missouri, Illinois, Texas, Iowa, Oklahoma, Nebraska, Arkansas and Mississippi).
Five of those men from Eastern Missouri have pleaded guilty to charges filed in federal court.. 56-year old Robert Hackman, of Foley; 50-year old Teddy “Teddy Boggart” Kiriakidis, of Leasburg; 34-year old Ronald Creech, of Leslie; 38-year old Michael “Missouri Mike” Morgan, of Hannibal; and, 35-year old Jack Ruppel, of Eldon had been indicted in Jefferson City. In federal court in St. Louis, all pleaded guilty to conspiracy to violate federal animal fighting laws and agreed to forfeit their weapons, dogs and dog fighting equipment.
Dog fighting is banned in each state, and is a felony in 40 of them. Each of the defendants faced up to five years in jail and a $250,000 fine for each charge, a class D felony. Each defendant was charged under 18 U.S.C. 371 (conspiracy), 7 U.S.C. 2156(a) and 18 U.S.C. 2 and 49 (sponsoring or exhibiting an animal in an animal fighting venture). However, under federal sentencing guidelines for the crimes pleaded to, each of these individuals could face from probation to six months in prison, depending on a variety of factors, including prior convictions.
In August 2007, Michael Vick (former star-quarterback and franchise player for the Atlanta Falcons) entered into a plea agreement and was suspended from the NFL. In December 2007, he was sentenced to 23 months in federal prison, and 3 years probation. The maximum sentence was 5 years in prison. A 3-year sentence in the state penitentiary was suspended upon condition of good behavior. Mr. Vick also paid $1M in penalties for the care and rehabilitation of some 60 dogs which were removed from his property at the time of his arrest. The discrepancy in sentences has lead to charges of racial discrimination by some parties.
“This was the largest dog fighting raid in US history, but it will not be the last” according to FBI Special Assistant Michael Kaste, who went to state that: “This case sets precedence for the FBI along with our local, state and federal partners to aggressively root out underground dog fighting rings where people have absolutely no qualms about torturing man’s best friend for money and entertainment.”
The Humane Society of Missouri is presently providing shelter, veterinary care and behavioral evaluation for 407 of the rescued dogs, and 100 puppies born since the rescue. Outside the courtroom, Hackman’s lawyer, Joel Schwartz, said the dogs were “incredibly well taken care of”(!) and most were healthy when seized. However, dogs associated with all the five individuals had numerous wounds and scars ; one was missing its lips; while another was missing a leg. Many reportedly had internal parasites, ear infections, and broken or missing teeth..
The initial raid may serve to dispel the myth that dogfighting involves uneducated, poor and/or rural citizens. One of the defendants, 48-year old Cris Bottcher worked as a nurse at a Bethany (MO) hospital. Another, 55-yr old Rick Hihath, was a physical education teacher. In a 1998 letter, Mr. Hihath wrote to a local newspaper, he claimed to have known about 50 “men,” some of whom he identified as “close friends,” who hosted cockfights. Mr. Hihath called them “good, old-fashioned American people.” Also dispelling the perception that only men are involved in dogfighting, at least one of the defendants, Jill Makstaller, is a woman.
For more info: www.examiner.com/examiner/x-9726-Seattle-Pet-Laws-Examiner~y2009m7d11-Biggest-dogfighting-bust-in-history.
Photo: AP Photo/The St. Louis Post-Dispatch, Emily Rasinski

Jeffrey Nanni and Maurice Kevin Smith were domestic partners for some 12 years. Nanni was a paralegal, while Smith headed his own construction company. Over the years, the couple had had a total of 12 dogs, including a 12-pound Chihuahua named Buster which Nanni adopted in 2005.

